What happened this past week.
February 10









February 11
Ethan and Dong Eun had an interesting talk about what makes something alive. Out of curiosity, Dong Eun asked if the planets and stars are alive.
Ethan said that it depends on what you consider alive. Ethan explained the different definitions of “alive.” Dong Eun asked what being alive meant and she said that something alive might have energy in order to come to life.
Ethan said some rocks have potential energy to roll down a hill but they’re not alive.
They talked about what else can define being alive.
Ethan said that maybe whether or not something can grow could be alive, but Dong Eun said that at the start of the solar system, everything clumped together to form planets and stars.
She asked if that should be a definition of being alive?
Ethan said that the earth is constantly being bombarded by meteorites and is growing but that doesn’t mean that the earth is alive.
Ethan finally suggested that something alive is something that can reproduce.
They finished the conversation with Dong Eun wanting to think more about Ethan’s last point and find a counterpoint.
She couldn’t find something to argue against Ethan’s point so they decided that perhaps Ethan’s definition of being alive is the most logical explanation.
Dong Eun said that even in humans, if our cells are no longer reproducing, we can’t live.





























He finished the night with some coding and read some questions and answers on the xkcd.com site.
February 12

















February 13













February 14













February 15
















February 16
Ethan was supposed to have symphony practice and skating lessons but there was no class this week because of Family Day.
However, we didn’t know about










Another week and we’re now into mid-February. We can see how Ethan has continued to progress in his learning.
Our call with Ethan’s LC, Natasha, helped reassure us that Ethan is doing well and to keep letting him lead the way in his learning.
That’s sort of the whole idea of SelfDesign and unschooling and it’s something we’re very happy about because of how happy Ethan is.
Ethan and Dong Eun had an interesting talk about what makes something alive. Out of curiosity, Dong Eun asked if the planets and stars are alive.
Ethan said that it depends on what you consider alive. Ethan explained the different definitions of “alive.” Dong Eun asked what being alive meant and she said that something alive might have energy in order to come to life.
Ethan finally suggested that something alive is something that can reproduce.
She couldn’t find something to argue against Ethan’s point so they decided that perhaps Ethan’s definition of being alive is the most logical explanation.
I think this is a very interesting discussion. What makes something alive? Ethan i am going to ask you some questions and propose some interesting theories to go further on this topic, if you are interested….
Have you ever heard of the Gaia theory. It is a theory which suggests that the earth is a self regulating system which is alive. You can learn more about the science upon which James Lovelock developed this theory. Let me know what you think.
The Gaia hypothesis, also known as Gaia theory or Gaia principle, proposes that all organisms and their inorganic surroundings on Earth are closely integrated to form a single and self-regulating complex system, maintaining the conditions for life on the planet. The scientific investigation of the Gaia hypothesis focuses on observing how the biosphere and the evolution of life forms contribute to the stability of global temperature, ocean salinity, oxygen in the atmosphere and other factors of habitability in a preferred homeostasis. The Gaia hypothesis was formulated by the chemist James Lovelock and co-developed by the microbiologist Lynn Margulis in the 1970s. Initially received with hostility by the scientific community, it is now studied in the disciplines of geophysiology and Earth system science, and some of its principles have been adopted in fields like biogeochemistry and systems ecology. This ecological hypothesis has also inspired analogies and various interpretations in social sciences, politics, and religion under a vague philosophy and movement.
Many people are involved in this discussion and debate. Here is just one example, read more at this link: https://www.researchgate.net/post/How_does_being_alive_or_Life_different_from_being_conscious_or_Consciousness
Person 1: Hey, I am interested in knowing what is Life and What is Consciousness? How different are they? How are they interconnected?
We have various life forms like plants, fungi and other microbial systems that we treat as living but science declare them not to have consciousness. So how is ‘living’ different from being ‘conscious’? Science declares that even advanced life forms like few animals don’t have consciousness.
So is it that: “Not all living entities have consciousness but all conscious beings or forms are living.”
Person 2:
I’d equal ‘living’ with ‘showing metabolic activity’. No presumptions about the amount of metabolic activity made.
‘Consciousness’ is different: where do you draw the line between consciousness and ‘mere reflexes’? Science is continuously redefining this line… OK, without a brain consciousness is hard to imagine. But how many nerve or brain cells are required to develop consciousness?
So here are my questions:
Is the earth a living being, a self regulating system? is the earth alive? Are stars alive?
What is the difference between alive and consciousness? Or how are they related?
The scientist Rupert Sheldrake (whom I have met and listened to this very talk) suggests that the sun is also indeed conscious.The talk is a bit long, but he is quite interesting. It might be a film you watch in a few years…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MEyT1tqz7vk&feature=youtu.be Is the Sun Conscious.
However Sheldrake has done some very fun and surprising research with dogs and their ability to sense when their owners are coming home. Doggie ESP (extra sensory powers). He likes to explore topics using scientific methods, but are on the edge of what everyday science says is possible.
This video is in German with English subtitles but one of the shorter easier ones I could find today: very cool.
I also wanted to share some really cool winter science activities in the Library.
https://selfdesign.learning.powerschool.com/selfdesignlearning/library/cms_page/view/29554346
You have had a lot of snow in Vancouver! It’s freezing here in Nelson, one of the coldest February’s I can remember.
I wanted to pass along a long list of resources from another LC.
If you see a book he would like, I have had learners in the past request them at their local library and the library will order, purchase and hold it for you…
Some resource recommendations to inspire further learning ~
Nick and Tesla Series by Bob Pflugfelder and Steve Hockensmith: High Voltage Danger Lab, Robot Army Rampage, Secret Agent Gadget Battle, Solar Powered Showdown, Super-Cyborg, Gadget Glove, Special Effects Spectacular
Nick and Tesla Series – Penguin Random House
The Story of Inventions by Anna Claybourne
Story Of Inventions: Anna Claybourne: 9781409555551: Books …
What If?: Serious Scientific Answers to Absurd Hypothetical Questions by Randall Munroe
What If?: Serious Scientific Answers to Absurd Hypothetical Questions …
The Thing Explainer: Complicated Stuff in Simple Words by Randall Munroe
Thing Explainer: Complicated Stuff in Simple Words: Randall Munroe …
Girls Think of Everything: Stories of Ingenious Inventions by Women by Catherine Thimmesh
Girls Think of Everything: Stories of Ingenious Inventions by Women …
The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill
The Girl Who Drank the Moon (Winner of the 2017 … – Amazon.ca
Escape from Mr. Lemoncello’s Library by Chris Grabenstein
Escape from Mr. Lemoncello’s Library: Chris Grabenstein – Amazon.ca
Read-Aloud Revival
Read-Aloud Revival
Superhuman Encyclopedia: Discover The Amazing Things Your Body Do
Super Human Encyclopedia: Discover the Amazing Things Your Body …
John Muir, Earth – Planet, Universe, by Julie Bertagna and William Goldsmith
John Muir, Earth – Planet, Universe by Julie Bertagna – Goodreads
Bold & Brave: Ten Heroes Who Won Women the Right to Vote: Kirsten …
Children’s Book Review: Bold and Brave: Ten Heroes Who Won …
I Dissent: Ruth Bader Ginsburg Makes Her Mark – Amazon Canada
YouTube: If Punctuation Had Sound
If Punctuations Had Sound, English would be so fun – YouTube
BUGGED: How Insects Changed History
Natural World: A Visual Compendium of Wonders From Nature
Birding Is My Favourite Video Game: Cartoons about the Natural Word from ‘Bird and Moon’ by Rosemary Mosco
Birding Is My Favorite Video Game: Cartoons about the … – Amazon.ca
Pacific Northwest Plant Knowledge Cards: Pacific Northwest Plant Knowledge Cards highlight 65 edible and medicinal plants from the Pacific Northwest coastal region. The cards include beautiful photographs and descriptions to help identify plants, names of the plants in three different Indigenous languages, including SENCOTEN, Hul’q’umi’num, and Dididaht. The cards were inspired by Feasting for Change: Reconnecting Food, Land & Culture where Elders and Knowledge Keepers led plant walks and discussions about edible and medicinal plants. Each card describes traditional uses and ways of harvesting each plant, featuring seasonal indicators and a legend to help quickly identify uses of each plant.
Pacific Northwest Plant Knowledge Cards – Resources | Vancouver …
Crystal Experiment:
How To Make Crystals with Borax Science Project for Kids
Borax Crystals: How to Grow Giant DIY Borax Crystals | Dans le …
Wildwood Chronicles
Wildwood (Wildwood Chronicles, #1) by Colin Meloy – Goodreads
Keeper Of The Lost Cities Series – Shannon Messenger
Cressida Cowell’s series starting with the Wizards of Once https://www.cressidacowell.co.uk/book/the-wizards-of-once/
Mashup Math MashUp Math
Carson-Dellosa Guinness World Records Math, Grade 3
Carson-Dellosa Guinness World Records Math, Grade 4
Canadian Girls Who Rocked the World
Canadian Girls Who Rocked the World: Tanya Lloyd Kyi – Amazon.ca
Canadian Boys who Rocked the World
Canadian Boys Who Rocked The World: Tanya Lloyd Kyi – Amazon.ca
Boys who Rocked the World
(U.S. version)
Boys Who Rocked the World: Heroes from King Tut to … – Amazon.ca
And finally,
cute factor is high in this resource 🙂
Recent Comments